L’Oréal Paris Extra-Intense Liquid Pencil Eyeliner ($9) A drugstore gem, this liner kicks the butt of some of its luxury counterparts—mainly because it glides on like liquid, but dries to a perfect, smudge-proof finish.
The five pencils that our panel tested, with our main pick, Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof, at the far left, and our runner-up, Too Faced, second from the left.
Finding the perfect eyeliner is a never-ending beauty task, especially since you have to choose between pencil, gel and liquid and a ton of applicator options. We have the best affordable drugstore eyeliners that will make the search easier and cheaper!
NYX GLIDE ON PENCIL (Best inner rim white eyeliner I have ever used. This liner is waterproof so it stays put and last for hrs. Use it to brighten up your eyes, or enlarge your pout by drawing above the cupids bow)
COMPARISON / SWATCHES :: Best Black Eye Khols / Eyeliner Pencils :: BLACKEST = Stila kajal in Onyx, MAC Smolder, Avon Supershock gel eyeliner in Black... BEST SMUDGING (4 smoky looks) = Korres soft eyeliner pencil in black (01), Stila kajal in Onyx, Une Absolute Blacks Khol in K01 (softer look)... SMUDGEPROOF (staying power) = Urban Decay glide on eye pencil in Zero, Avon Supershock in Black... SOFTEST KHOL = Stila, MAC Feline or Avon! | #eyekhol #blackeyeliner #eyelinerpencil…