NEW! Milani Supreme Kohl Kajal Eyeliner (blackest black) $5.99 Soft but serious. With this new eyeliner, you get it all – and then some. While kohl pencils are usually way too smudgy to neatly line the inner rim, this glide-on, precision number gets right in there. Tightlining, waterlining, adding definition to the upper lid - there’s nothing this one-stroke wonder can’t do. And such versatility!