Best Island Runner-Up: Culebra, Puerto Rico. "This is a slice of bygone Caribbean, with not even a hint of a big resort or cruise ship," our reporters say. (Click through to see full list of Outside Magazine's 2012 Travel Awards.
La Concha Renaissance San Juan Resort San Juan With an outdoor infinity pool overlooking Condado Beach, this 4 star resort features a casino and several fine dining restaurants. The large guestrooms have private sea view balconies.